Skip to main content
Read page text
page 2
VOLUME 2, NUMBER 2 FEBRUARY-APRIL 2017 3 Julia Wallace The Rohingyas by Azeem Ibrahim 4 Maung Sein Win "Artificial weather machine" Scott Bywater "mother tongue" 5 Sebastian Strangio Cambodia Votes by Michael Sullivan 7 Martin Stuart-Fox A Great Place to Have a War: America in Laos and the Birth of a Military C.I.A. by Joshua Kurlantzick 8 Nguyen Q Khai A writers' writer 10 Nguyen Binh Phuong "A haircut" 11 Nick Freeman The Myanmar Economy: Its Past, Present and Prospects by Konosuke Odaka (ed) 12 Chris Taylor The Beautiful Country and the Middle Kingdom: America and China by John Pomfret Stilwell and the American Experience in China: 1911-1945 by Barbara W. Tuchman 14 Vu Duc Liem Borderlands 15 Erik W. Davis Cambodia's Second Kingdom: Nation, Imagination, and Democracy by Astrid Norén-Nilsson Bunkong Tuon "Khmer Krom" 16 Michael Freeman The Face of the Buddha by William Empson 18 Emma Larkin The English Governess at the Siamese Court and The Romance of the Harem by Anna Leonowens Anna and the King of Siam by Margaret Landon Yul: The Man Who Would be King by Rock Brynner Masked: The Life of Anna Leonowens, Schoolmistress at the Court of Siam by Alfred Habegger 20 Robert Horne Made in Cambodia 21 Adair Richards Cambodia Noir by Nick Seeley Hunters in the Dark by Lawrence Osborne Peppered Justice by Mark Bibby Jackson The Temple of the Leper King by Bob Couttie Angkor Away by Steven W. Palmer Chath Piersath "To Emily Dickinson" 22 Reaksmey Yean Sopheap rises Oslo Davis Such A Lovely Little War by Marcelino Truong Wayne McCallum The Great Soul of Siberia: In Search of the Elusive Siberian Tiger by Sooyong Park 25 Easterine Kire I say Poona 26 Letters Adam Jasper, Milton Osborne Chat Tomuk Martin Stuart-Fox is emeritus professor of history at the University of Queensland, Australia. He is the author of several books and numerous articles on Laos. Footnotes for his article are available from the author at m.stuartfox@uq.edu.au. Nick Freeman is an independent economic development consultant based in Yangon. mekongreview.com Bunkong Tuon teaches writing and literature at Union College, in Schenectady, New York. His first collection of poetry, Gruel , was published in 2015. Oslo Davis is an illustrator, artist and cartoonist from Melbourne, Australia. Easterine Kire is a Nagaland-born poet and novelist who now lives in Norway. Erik W. Davis is associate professor of religious studies at Macalester College. His latest book is Deathpower, Buddhism's Ritual Imagination in Cambodia. Khai Q. Nguyen is a writer and editor based in Ho Chi Minh City. His first book, Désir et sommeil, a novella in French, came out last year. Chath Piersath is a Cambodian poet and artist. EDITOR Minh Bui Jones ASSOCIATE EDITOR Rupert Winchester DESIGNER Robert Starkweather SUB-EDITOR Allen Myers COVER ILLUSTRATOR Damien Chavanat, ARTISTS Elsie Herberstein, Oslo Davis Contact: PO Box 847, Leichhardt NSW 2040, Australia; editor@mekongreview.com Mekong Review is published four times a year; next issue May 2017 2
page 3
MYANMAR The Rohingya Julia Wallace The first thing U Kyaw Hla Aung asked when he met me, after I walked up the muddy lane to his house and climbed the rough-hewn stairs to the balcony where he spends much of his time, sitting and waiting, is whether I wanted to see his documents. He keeps them in a fat green plastic folder, but they have long since burst their confines and spilled out the sides, like an uncontainable force. “This is my lawyer certificate … These are the land ownership documents of my four grandparents … My father’s name … My uncle …” These papers and photographs represent just a small fraction of what the Rohingya Muslim lawyer and activist has accumulated in his seventy-six years, but they are all he managed to save when a fire destroyed his house on 11 June 2012. That month, sectarian violence convulsed his hometown of Sittwe, the capital city of Rakhine state, also known as Arakan, on the far western frontier of Myanmar, sprawling out along the Bay of Bengal. Tens of thousands of Rohingya were beaten and burned out of their homes by the state’s majority Buddhists; many others fled the country. The situation of the Muslims of Rakhine was already tenuous, but the violence in 2012 set off a crisis that is still ongoing. U Kyaw Hla Aung has not been back home since that day. After being detained briefly on trumped-up charges, and then for a longer stint in jail the following year, he, along with his wife and three of their daughters, found a house on the edge of Thak Kay Pyin, one of a colony of squalid camps that has metastasised along the coast to the southwest of the city, housing an estimated 120,000 Rohingya. On a recent trip to Thak Kay Pyin and several adjacent camps, I braced myself for extravagant horrors, but many of the worst problems there, I realised, were hidden. Instead, the overwhelming impression was of stultifying boredom: the small, repeated horror of an empty life, of non-existence, waking up every day to realise that you are stuck and at the mercy of those who hate you. Like everywhere else in Myanmar, the ground in the camps is stained with blood-red gobs of betel spit; there are markets selling cell phones and hijabs; there are tea shops where a hundred kyat can buy you a mug of milk-sweetened brew or powdered coffee. But unlike in the tea shops of Yangon or Mandalay, which host excited deal-making and arguments about the news, the men here are sprawled around listlessly, free of many of the obligations of daily life, but also the pleasures: making one’s own way, stealing a moment from a busy day to rest. Here, these moments of rest are all that exist, punctuated by the twice-daily call to prayer. “Life here is very … not so happy,” U Kyaw Hla Aung said wryly. A lawyer and former court clerk who ran for parliament in the 1980s, he is probably the best educated and wealthiest Rohingya here, the luckiest. The nature of his luck, then, is that he can afford to pay the bribes and sureties required to leave the area every now and then to travel to Yangon for medical treatment; he meets with UN officials and diplomats who pop in and out of the camps on brief “fact-finding” missions; and he sits and waits on a plastic chair in a tiny wooden house, rather than on a stool in a tea shop or a muddy stoop. The documents were the first thing U Kyaw Hla Aung wanted to talk about because documentation, or the lack of it, has become the heart of the Rohingya story. The official justification for keeping the Rohingya in a state of de facto apartheid is that they are illegal immigrants who have seeped across the border from Bangladesh. But citizenship in Myanmar, under a 1982 Greg Constantine A makeshift camp outside Sittwe, capital of Rakhine State, October 2012 law enacted by the military government, is a complex tangle of rules in which only members of 135 designated “national ethnicities” can ever be granted full rights. Even those who clearly qualify often have difficulty obtaining the correct documents; for the Rohingya, who are definitively off the list, it is impossible. So the documents they do have are more precious than almost anything else; they seem to offer a kind of proof that they belong in the place where they live. Before the 1962 coup that set off more than four decades of brutal military rule, U Kyaw Hla Aung said, he and his family took it for granted that they were citizens. They attended public schools and were issued state documents without a second thought. The documents that emerge from his folder are a motley assortment of colonial-era and postindependence certificates and photographs. There is a black-and-white photograph of the Weight-Lifters’ Association of University College Rangoon, a group of rather scrawny Burmese men, arms crossed in front of them and fiercely staring down the camera, a stack of barbells crossed in front of them. Instinctive citizens of the land. A picture of the Muslim Association of Rangoon University, 1958–9. “At that time it was normal, you can see … All these students are Rohingya, they were studying at Rangoon University …” A certificate declares, in luscious cursive, that Mahamed Rasim, son of Mahamed Yusoof Abdul Badom, born 16 December 1941, is eligible to matriculate at the University of Rangoon. A 1939 certificate of registration from the Burma Medical Council, stamped with a red seal, certifies an ancestor known as Habibullah to practise medicine in Parein, a lush rural village several hours north of Sittwe. And in his identity documents, a young U Kyaw Hla Aung looks into the camera with the startled stare of a child in the days before cameras were ubiquitous. In front of him a sign bears his ID number, AH028744. Another, similar, paper shows a teenage U Kyaw Hla Aung, still AH028744. “This is my pension book — it is me!” he said. In the rich literature of bureaucracy that arose alongside the modern state, there is a strong focus on the dehumanising aspects of the documents and certificates and offices that are integral to statecraft. Less obvious are the ways in which those same bureaucratic rules, by being blind to human difference, may confer protection and even a kind of humanity. In U Kyaw Hla Aung’s green folder, he also holds a document that is not personal. It is a heavily underlined and highlighted photocopy of a 1799 article on the languages of Burma by the Scottish polymath and physician Francis Buchanan, who travelled through Asia as a ship’s doctor, cataloguing plants, places and people as he went. His passion for botany made him particularly keen on classification in all its forms. U Kyaw Hla Aung read aloud: “I shall now add three dialects, spoken in the Burma empire, but evidently derived from the language of the Hindu nation. The first is that spoken by the Mohammedans, who have been long settled in Arakan, and who call themselves Rooingas, or natives of Arakan .” He looked up in triumph, as if something had been settled. Many Rohingya activists and advocates see this passage as definitive proof that their Muslim ancestors were living within what is now Myanmar several decades before British colonisation. The truth is far more complex. Some Rakhine Muslims have very deep roots in the area; others are believed to have migrated across the border much later, in the mid-twentieth century; still others might be more recent arrivals. Many are so poor, uneducated and desperate that they cannot trace how their families arrived. The term “Rohingya” was not widely used until relatively recently, as U Kyaw Hla Aung himself notes; it is a largely political construction, born of increasing sectarian violence and persecution. A great deal of the recent debate over the Rohingya 3

MYANMAR

The Rohingya

Julia Wallace

The first thing U Kyaw Hla Aung asked when he met me, after I walked up the muddy lane to his house and climbed the rough-hewn stairs to the balcony where he spends much of his time, sitting and waiting, is whether I wanted to see his documents.

He keeps them in a fat green plastic folder, but they have long since burst their confines and spilled out the sides, like an uncontainable force.

“This is my lawyer certificate … These are the land ownership documents of my four grandparents … My father’s name … My uncle …”

These papers and photographs represent just a small fraction of what the Rohingya Muslim lawyer and activist has accumulated in his seventy-six years, but they are all he managed to save when a fire destroyed his house on 11 June 2012. That month, sectarian violence convulsed his hometown of Sittwe, the capital city of Rakhine state, also known as Arakan, on the far western frontier of Myanmar, sprawling out along the Bay of Bengal.

Tens of thousands of Rohingya were beaten and burned out of their homes by the state’s majority Buddhists; many others fled the country. The situation of the Muslims of Rakhine was already tenuous, but the violence in 2012 set off a crisis that is still ongoing. U Kyaw Hla Aung has not been back home since that day. After being detained briefly on trumped-up charges, and then for a longer stint in jail the following year, he, along with his wife and three of their daughters, found a house on the edge of Thak Kay Pyin, one of a colony of squalid camps that has metastasised along the coast to the southwest of the city, housing an estimated 120,000 Rohingya.

On a recent trip to Thak Kay Pyin and several adjacent camps, I braced myself for extravagant horrors, but many of the worst problems there, I realised, were hidden. Instead, the overwhelming impression was of stultifying boredom: the small, repeated horror of an empty life, of non-existence, waking up every day to realise that you are stuck and at the mercy of those who hate you. Like everywhere else in Myanmar, the ground in the camps is stained with blood-red gobs of betel spit; there are markets selling cell phones and hijabs; there are tea shops where a hundred kyat can buy you a mug of milk-sweetened brew or powdered coffee. But unlike in the tea shops of Yangon or Mandalay, which host excited deal-making and arguments about the news, the men here are sprawled around listlessly, free of many of the obligations of daily life, but also the pleasures: making one’s own way, stealing a moment from a busy day to rest. Here, these moments of rest are all that exist, punctuated by the twice-daily call to prayer.

“Life here is very … not so happy,” U Kyaw Hla Aung said wryly. A lawyer and former court clerk who ran for parliament in the 1980s, he is probably the best educated and wealthiest Rohingya here, the luckiest. The nature of his luck, then, is that he can afford to pay the bribes and sureties required to leave the area every now and then to travel to Yangon for medical treatment; he meets with UN officials and diplomats who pop in and out of the camps on brief “fact-finding” missions; and he sits and waits on a plastic chair in a tiny wooden house, rather than on a stool in a tea shop or a muddy stoop.

The documents were the first thing U Kyaw Hla Aung wanted to talk about because documentation, or the lack of it, has become the heart of the Rohingya story. The official justification for keeping the Rohingya in a state of de facto apartheid is that they are illegal immigrants who have seeped across the border from Bangladesh. But citizenship in Myanmar, under a 1982

Greg Constantine

A makeshift camp outside Sittwe, capital of Rakhine State, October 2012

law enacted by the military government, is a complex tangle of rules in which only members of 135 designated “national ethnicities” can ever be granted full rights. Even those who clearly qualify often have difficulty obtaining the correct documents; for the Rohingya, who are definitively off the list, it is impossible.

So the documents they do have are more precious than almost anything else; they seem to offer a kind of proof that they belong in the place where they live. Before the 1962 coup that set off more than four decades of brutal military rule, U Kyaw Hla Aung said, he and his family took it for granted that they were citizens. They attended public schools and were issued state documents without a second thought.

The documents that emerge from his folder are a motley assortment of colonial-era and postindependence certificates and photographs. There is a black-and-white photograph of the Weight-Lifters’ Association of University College Rangoon, a group of rather scrawny Burmese men, arms crossed in front of them and fiercely staring down the camera, a stack of barbells crossed in front of them. Instinctive citizens of the land. A picture of the Muslim Association of Rangoon University, 1958–9. “At that time it was normal, you can see … All these students are Rohingya, they were studying at Rangoon University …”

A certificate declares, in luscious cursive, that Mahamed Rasim, son of Mahamed Yusoof Abdul Badom, born 16 December 1941, is eligible to matriculate at the University of Rangoon. A 1939 certificate of registration from the Burma Medical Council, stamped with a red seal, certifies an ancestor known as Habibullah to practise medicine in Parein, a lush rural village several hours north of Sittwe.

And in his identity documents, a young U Kyaw Hla Aung looks into the camera with the startled stare of a child in the days before cameras were ubiquitous. In front of him a sign bears his ID number, AH028744. Another, similar, paper shows a teenage U Kyaw Hla Aung, still AH028744.

“This is my pension book — it is me!” he said. In the rich literature of bureaucracy that arose alongside the modern state, there is a strong focus on the dehumanising aspects of the documents and certificates and offices that are integral to statecraft. Less obvious are the ways in which those same bureaucratic rules, by being blind to human difference, may confer protection and even a kind of humanity.

In U Kyaw Hla Aung’s green folder, he also holds a document that is not personal. It is a heavily underlined and highlighted photocopy of a 1799 article on the languages of Burma by the Scottish polymath and physician Francis Buchanan, who travelled through Asia as a ship’s doctor, cataloguing plants, places and people as he went. His passion for botany made him particularly keen on classification in all its forms.

U Kyaw Hla Aung read aloud: “I shall now add three dialects, spoken in the Burma empire, but evidently derived from the language of the Hindu nation. The first is that spoken by the Mohammedans, who have been long settled in Arakan, and who call themselves Rooingas, or natives of Arakan .”

He looked up in triumph, as if something had been settled.

Many Rohingya activists and advocates see this passage as definitive proof that their Muslim ancestors were living within what is now Myanmar several decades before British colonisation. The truth is far more complex. Some Rakhine Muslims have very deep roots in the area; others are believed to have migrated across the border much later, in the mid-twentieth century; still others might be more recent arrivals. Many are so poor, uneducated and desperate that they cannot trace how their families arrived. The term “Rohingya” was not widely used until relatively recently, as U Kyaw Hla Aung himself notes; it is a largely political construction, born of increasing sectarian violence and persecution.

A great deal of the recent debate over the Rohingya

3

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content